One more minor correction Re: More on Turkels latest (Part 5)

• Messages sorted by: [ date ][ thread ][ subject ][ author ]

Thanks to Jason Filley, who just pointed out that Turkels G1 is of the 
Priestly, not the Elohist, layer (a point I was unclear on.) 


>Achilles

> haven't seen him do this, have you?) - if the JEDP hypothesis is correct,

> then G2 and G1 were written by different men, in different settings, at

> different times and for different purposes. If that is the case, then it

> is even more senseless and, yes, I will even say arrogant, for Turkel to

> castigate the poor fellow who wrote this for failing to anticipate G1 and

> harmonize his account with it, when G1 had not even been written yet, and

> would not be for around 110 years! 


Should read "would not be for around 340 years!" 


/Achilles     achillesz@usa.net

All rights reserved.

Random thought for the moment:

    Goodness without wisdom always accomplished evil.
           -- Valentine Michael Smith in  Stranger in a Strange Land

• Previous message: Tall Tale
• Next message: Rule of "Audience" (Was re: The Rich Man)
• Messages sorted by: [ date ][ thread ][ subject ][ author ]