Carter's Hero Goofs Again

• Messages sorted by: [ date ][ thread ][ subject ][ author ]

At 03:54 PM 1/31/99 -0500, Jason Carter wrote:

>>TILL

>>The argument hasn't been lost until Turkel steps into an open forum like

>>this, presents his case, and leaves his opponents unable to answer him.  He

>>hasn't done that yet, and he isn't going to do it.  I would gladly take his

>>article and reply to it point by point, but I know from experience that

>>Turkel will only write another web page in which he selectively quotes from

>>my answers only what he wants his readers to see and leaves untouched

>>arguments that are damaging to his case. Get the guy to post his arguments

>>here and to defend them and then crow about how Crea has "lost the argument."

>

>CARTER

>Please Till - as of now, umm...no one has been able to answer him or me. 

>Why don't you do your point by point and prove to everyone here that you're

>really committed to finding truth, rather than whining us to death with

>your ego-feeding pleas. 

>


TILL
Well, as a matter of fact, I just sent a posting that replies to the first
part of his "article," so when you see it, perhaps you would care to reply.
As for the rest of Turkel's article, I will reply to his other points, when
he agrees to engage in the open-forum debate.  Otherwise, I see no need to
reply to his "points," because he will just put another article on his web
page that selectively quotes what he wants his readers to see from my
responses but ignores the rest.

There is a second possibility.  Post your promise that if I reply to
Turkel's article point-by-point, your will serve as his stand-in and reply
to me point by point with an effort that is comparable to what I put into my
rebuttals.  If you will make that commitment, I'll start replying to
Turkel's other "points" as soon as I have delivered the next copy of TSR to
the printer, which will take about another week.  However, if you think that
I am going to put the time and effort into a thorough reply to Turkel that
you will just ignore, then you're mistaken.

By the way, did I ever send you my 28-part reply to Turkel on the Jehu
massacre? If not, I will be glad to send all 28 parts to you along with a
two-part analysis of his sources, which shows that he misrepresented the
sources he quoted.  These postings will show you how easy it is to rip
Turkel to pieces.





Farrell Till
Skepticism, Inc.
jftill@midwest.net

• Previous message: Carter's Hero Goofs Again
• Next message: Genesis 2:19
• Messages sorted by: [ date ][ thread ][ subject ][ author ]